That is untrue. You can add cards that do new things, rather than adding cards that are just more power. It’s been done, it can BE done.
New Player Query
I think you’re wrong on this one. Decks don’t necessarily get stronger because new cards that are individually stronger are printed. Decks also get stronger because new cards that yield new synergies with existing cards are printed. I’d argue that you could do nothing but print completely balanced cards and still end up increasing the overall power level of the possible decks just because of synergistic effects.
Which game has expanded on its card pool without increasing the overall strength of what’s possible with said card pool?
1 Like
By my oppinion of one month playing guy, Duelyst is a right choice. I came here from HS too, because its changing meta was too expensive for player like me, who dont give money for packs and everything else. In Duelyst it is better. Orbs has better drop rate of legendary and epics, you get better rewards in the en of the month, you can hit rank 5 with deck that costs 900 Spirit. At least try it and you will see it is good! 
Rotating cards out is necessary in the long run to keep the game fresh.
Take a certain mana cost. There is currently a best-in-slot card for that cost. In order to make a card from a new expansion replace that card as the new best-in-slot this new card must be better. If it is not better people will just continue to play the old card that they already have in their collection. So with each expansion cards will have to become powerful which inevitably will lead to power creep, which also essentially makes older cards unplayable over time.
In my opinion the least bad solution is actually to force the rotation of cards with a current and a legacy format like HS has done.
If X is BIS for that mana slot…Then you add cards with different mechanics and synergies, NOT cards that are flat better. Common mistake.
Also, BIS is rarely possible if you’re balancing the game. At no point should any card be the best to put in X mana slot for every deck in the game. If there IS a card doing that (Do we all remember Doctor Boom, in HS?) Then it needs to be nerfed, not rotated out.
2 Likes
I am also opposed to formats. Of course, I might change my mind in 10 years.
But right now I am really opposed to it.
I think there’s a good chance they’ll try very hard to not require formats.
As for guarantees, I think there are none.
Of course, if they split the formats over the same game content and such, it may not be all that bad…
2 ladders, 2 guantlets, etc. I can be king of ‘old’ and a noob in ‘new’. Could be okay actually.
But, I am hoping for no formats
3 Likes
Even if the old card and the new card will have different mechanics one of them will be stronger in a certain type of deck, one of them will be the new BIS for that deck and see play while the other one will not be played. Having two cards that are exactly the same power level is practically impossible in a game with stats based on integer values.
For example take the beloved Makantor Warbeast which is Magmar’s BIS for 6 mana. Suggest a new card that has exactly the same power level.
Still a bit new, as the title mentions, so…Haven’t even seen that card yet.
It is 6 mana 4/4 with Rush (Charge) and Frenzy (damages every foe around it)… OP
I can’t be sure (Again, I’m new) But that does sound pretty OP. So replacing it isn’t the best move, nerfing it is. IF it is OP, IDK for sure.
Makantor was just an example. Take any other card like, let us say, the Silverguard Knight which I would say is Lyonar’s BIS for 3 mana and an autoinclude. What card would be exactly equal to that one?
This is balanced I mean, because every Magmar deck is playing that, because it is one of cards around them Magmar is build. It is something like Flamewreathed Faceles or Savana Highmare in HS…
something beefy with healing synergy for ziran perhaps?
Perhaps. My point is when you get down to stats and actually try to express your idea in integer numbers there are limited possibilities for fine tuning and one of these two cards will almost inevitably end up as the stronger one over the other.
Dr. Boom was an extremely stupid OP card. But Duelyst has nothing that awful.
1 Like
Not since Kron got wrecked, anyway
1 Like
Thats true, but even so I think Inquisitor Boom was stronger than Dr. Kron. Kron was also nerfed eventually and according to the wiki Boom is still untouched.
At least you could only have 1 legendary in HS just imagine how much more often you would have seen him if you could run 2 copies. Would have almost literally been double the times lol.
It absolutly does not have to happen, and it currently is nothing like that, they do a fairly good job balancing things. I would not worry about it as its not even a concern untill way down the line.
I think Duelyst will likely have different phases of cards as you say.
The difference in duelyst is however, that it is much easier to obtain rare cards. You can actually keep up with the meta and expansions as a casual player who does the daily quests.
So. I’m not worried.
This topic was automatically closed 14 days after the last reply. New replies are no longer allowed.