I had a bad experience back then for typing out of frustration and I will try to refrain that same thing from happening again.
Topic: Is thumping wave just fine as it is? Or is it too strong?
Like I feel that card itself is ridiculously good, you can use it to just face race ur opponent if needed. As that is usually how magmar functions, remove minions, fight for board, hit face with their bbs and high attack minions, and makantor jesus usually closes up the game.
But my main concern is not really the +5 attack as u need a minion to function, it’s the other half of the text. "transform a minion into a 3-3 Kin (battlepet) at the end of the turn. It’s one of the cleanest removals in the game for 3 mana o.o
For instance, Abyssian has to destroy a minion and trigger deathwishes for 5. Same for Vetruvians as they have to destory a minion nearby for 4. Lyonar has matyrdom that heals the opponent for destorying a minion completely. Vanar is known for having cheap and efficient removals but they dont always remove the entire body. Songhai has a 3 mana transform into an unattack-able 0-2 panda (which is also too cheap imo), But thumping wave just transforms a minion into a 3-3 kin that kills itself when u place ur magmar general next to it with bbs+1, as that’s when u usually use thumping wave; when the big guys drop down and both players can use their bbs for at least once now.
Like isnt it too good for 3 mana? Looking for feedback, just curious about the power level of the card.