Those games have coin flip metas which are worse.
the only time rock, paper, scissors format have been done well was 2014’s triangle meta in YGO.
Shaddolls beats Burning Abyss
Burning Abyss beats Qliphort
Qliphort beats Shaddolls
Burning Abyss was actually the best in that format because it had a fairly even Shaddoll match up but it beat Qliphort.
Games that are decided before the first turn aren’t fun to play because you already know who will win and in triangle format’s case it was an incredibly skillful format so you wouldn’t already know who wins.