Duelyst Forums

Do you think Kara BBS and Saberspine tiger is a balanced interaction?

#33

The problem with rush is not the 3 out of hand damage. It is 3 out of hand damage + mobility the card gives you. You can rush to remote threats, get into provoke positions, get off positioning-based spells like holy immolation. And on top of that you can use buffs to deal massive damage and then have a body left on the board for future use. With Phoenix Fire you just deal 3 damage and that’s it. With a tiger you can deal more damage by investing additional cards and have a body the opponent needs to get rid off. And it also gives you more reach.

The card itself isn’t scary. It’s flexibility is. Remember Third Wish Tiger times? Any powerful buff the CP wants to put in will be limited by Tiger being a thing. That is basically the only reason I want to see rush changed.

Oh, and Kara interaction is totally fine, you need to invest heavily to build those huge tigers, plus anybody playing against Kara should anticipate them, so there is no surprise factor.

#34

I don’t think it’s a major imbalance at the moment. I mean, we live in an environment of insane uninterruptible damage the likes of chainable Shadow Nova, Spectral Revenant, Makantor War666 + Rush friends, Spirit of the Wild, and Chakri/Inner Fire/Killing Edge/Mist Dragon Seal/Saberspine Seal/Juxtaposition shenanigans, etc. I mean, it’s…the norm.

If you haven’t got the mad uninterruptible damage and your guns have to ask your opponents “May I?” (textbook example: Aymara Healer), then your faction sucks mucho ass unless you have some kind of ungodly ludicrous cheapass payoffs if your opponent answers “Sigh. Fine.”, to the order of Holy Immolation double Divine Bond for 28 or something.

As CP continues to dismantle uninterruptible damage the likes of Vindicator, chainable Shadow Nova, etc. one-by-one, eventually they will need to take away the Kineticats™, too. One faction in Vetruvicissitude™ is a major imbalance you can live with, because most of the factions are still relatively balanced at the top. When you get to three, four, or god forbid five factions in Vetruvicissitude™, it goes from a major imbalance to a Clusterduck™.

2 Likes
#35

1 Like
#36

After playing pretty much only Vanar since I started and getting destroyed by tactical 10+ damage instant nukes from various classes during basically every season, it feels pretty good to be on the nuking side for once.
But yes, change rush, it’s too binary and limits design-space for all future cards to come. I like the ‘no movement’ idea, since it meshes well with the whole tactical board game thing.

1 Like
#37

I’ve played about 30ish games with a deck very similar to The Scientist’s midrange Kara deck and I can say quite a few games come down to hoarding a tiger or two in hand hoping my opponent gets close enough that I can finish them off.

The problem I have is that Tigers in the typical Kara deck become not so different from Dank Memesis (Dark Nemesis). When DN hits the field it puts a strict timer on the game forcing your opponent to deal with the minion or die within a few turns. What sucks is that Tiger is a 3-mana common and DN is a 7 mana Legendary, yet they both operate almost the same way under these conditions. Somehow I doubt the designer’s intention was for Tiger to be used in this way.

I think the most simple solution is to make Kara’s bbs “Give all minions in your hand +1/+1 for this turn only”. No other bbs in the game is getting anywhere near the kind of value that Kara gets in a 9+ turn game and it’s a little strange to have a general whose bbs is central to their win condition. I feel like it’s backwards to want to change the entire Rush mechanic or even nerf Tiger just because there’s an insanely powerful bbs out there. Just nerf what deserves to be nerfed.

1 Like
#38

Imma letchu finish
But Twin Fang Skorn mag is the best thing ever.
That’s all.

1 Like
#39

That hits the nail on the head! (Is this good English? If not: It’s OK laughing at me. :sunglasses:)

#40

Nope, you hit the nail on the head hehe
Perfect English

#41

The poor nail tho

#42

Not necessarily. Warbeast, Revenant, and Tiger are all infamous for what they can do with Rush. The ability to both move and attack on the turn it’s played is incredibly powerful, more so than many other abilities. Personally speaking, I vote for the idea to make it an ‘or’ option. A minion with Rush can either move OR attack when it’s played. So you have to choose between damage or positioning.

1 Like
#43

It’s so sad when we are almost knocking the Kara, and suddenly she goes not 1 but 2 Tigers with 7/6!

1 Like
#44

CP would have to rework the Ranged keyword also when touching Rush the way you want. A rushed Tiger (Makantor, Elu) is the only way to get rid of ranged minions without dispel. And dispel is really needed for other things - especially when you look at the cards that come with Shimzar (Silverguard Knights from Sky Phalanx, Soboros Death Touch, Beastmaster, Visionar).

1 Like
#45

I’ve just lost to a 2x kara-buffed-tigers in the same round, so in perfect anger and saltiness I can agree on nerfing this combo to the ground. Thanks sirs.

#46

FeelsSajjMan.
I’ve lost to a Kara that had 2 Zenruis one after the other. I agree, NERF HER!

1 Like
#47

I have been tilted by match after match where I play flawlessly, get kara down to lower health in the late game, and then get slammed by two tigers that have been hanging out in her hand since the opening draw. I get that holding two cards that long would limit options for her, but having to deal with all the provoke, disenchant, and transform it gets very tiring. Sit back and try range?..here comes disenchant and face with bbs spam. Go face?..provoke and bbs spam. Mirror match?..pray to RNG gods…double bbs spam. :stuck_out_tongue_winking_eye:

Sure, I could tech in stuff all day and lose to every other faction, live and die a slave to the meta, or ragequit like a three-year old. I’m not a fan of being forced into a corner when deck building. I’d rather stick to my pretentious attitude toward netdecking, but that’s just me.

I have only been successful in winning matches against kara where I went Super-agro-swarm-face, but I don’t find any challenge or fun in that.

I guess I might be crazy but winning in 4 turns just for the sake of winning does not appeal to me as much as a strategy-heavy battle. That’s why I fell in love with this game!

Of course, this is all could be a moot issue when the expansion drops. We can bitch about it until we’re all blue in the face, but it won’t help anyone to wallow in that much negativity. I’ll try to enjoy my little salt pile. :grin:

tl:dr Kara’s bbs is annoying but we’ll see what happens in a few weeks.

3 Likes
#48

That honestly sounds fair. Ranged minions pay for their safety with subpar stats already. Right now, Rush is basically a counter to everything. Ranged? Rush it. Taunt? Rush it. Why use Flying when Rush does the job better in 90% of all situations?

Hell, now that I thought about it, if anything Flying should be the counter to ranged. Something that can attack anything should be vulnerable to something that can move anywhere.

#49

Maybe you’re right with flying. But then (just my taste) every faction needs a cheap flying minion…


2 Mana 2/2, Flying, Death Watch: If this minion kills a minion with the Ranged keyword it dies.

Edit: card text

#50

I don’t think Rush is that big of a problem. It’s very strong, but so far is in manageable quantities. I don’t think there should be a “deck’s worth” of Rush minions, but 1-2 isn’t bad.

I think Kara’s BBS should limited to Vanar faction minions. This gives players serious pause before running a Tiger (which they can still buff with Frostfire). It also encourages faction flavor. The devs can then choose in future to give Vanar a Rush minion (probably for higher cost than 3). Kara will still have her revolving door 4/3 Snow Chasers and with the new Vespyrs coming out, people will be encouraged to play them. This also leaves Tiger alone for Lyonar, etc. where it isn’t nearly as broken.

1 Like
#51

Kara’s BBS should either apply to one minion at a time, only Vanar faction minions, or only be applicable once on any minion. And to be honest I’m disappointed in people who point out unfair interactions in other games as if that justifies this. It is silly to suggest that just because other games suck, this game should suck too.

#52

People still complain about Kara’s BBS in the new patch? Swear to god you guys are doing this for the lols at this point rather than actually believing what you’re saying.